Order Online
powered by BentoBox
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Bay Shore

Join our Waitlist or Order Online

Hours & Location

9 South Park Avenue,
Bay Shore, NY 11706
631-647-9560
support@toastcoffeehouse.com

Monday-Friday 8-3

Weekends - 8-3:30

Get Directions

Early Riser

  • We carry freshly baked local muffins and gourmet bagels Muffin: $2.59 | Bagel: $2.59 | Cream Cheese: $3.59

  • Organic Oatmeal

    With cinnamon apples and dried cranberry topped with brown sugar and strawberries

    $6.95

    $8.95

  • Avocado Toast

    Toasted multi-grain bread with sliced avocado & red onion served with homefries

    $9.95

  • Fruit Parfait Bowl

    Fresh fruit & berries on top of vanilla yogurt and covered with organic harvest granola

    $9.95

  • Avo BLT Toast

    Avocado with bacon, micro greens, and tomato with homefries

    $10.95

Eggs & Omelets

  • Served with home fries and toast, sub fruit $1.50 Add multi-grain, cinnamon swirl, English muffin or bagel $1.50 * Small size subtract $2.00 * Sub egg whites $2.50

  • Eggs Any Style

    Two organic farm fresh eggs, your choice of bacon, ham, sausage, or turkey bacon, served with home fries and toast

    $11.95

  • Splendid Benedict

    Two organic poached eggs served with sliced avocado fritter on a toasted English muffin, topped with hollandaise & maple bacon crumbles

    $15.95

  • Benedict Arnold

    Two organic poached eggs served on toasted English muffin, grilled ham, roasted red pepper, green onions & topped with hollandaise sauce

    $15.95

  • Corned Beef Hash & Eggs

    Two organic poached eggs, corned beef hash on homebaked tye topped with hollandaise sauce, caramelized Brussel sprouts & bacon

    $15.95

  • Biscuits & Gravy

    Two organic poached eggs served with homemade biscuits and sausage gravy

    $14.95

  • Plain Jane Omelet

    American Cheese

    $11.95

  • Avocado BLT Omelet

    Avocado, crisp bacon, spinach, and plum tomato with Vermont white cheddar cheese

    $14.95

  • Delancey Street

    Crispy bacon, spinach, mushroom, tomato, onion & swiss cheese

    $13.95

  • Huevos Migas Omelet

    Chorizo sausage, tomato, green pepper, onion & jalapeno Havarti

    $14.95

    spicy

  • Mediterranean Omelet

    Baby spinach, plum tomato, onion & feta

    $13.95

  • The Dig Me Omelet

    Egg whites, spinach, turkey & jack cheese

    $14.95

  • Steak & Eggs

    Two organic farm fresh eggs, choice hanger steak served with homefries & homemade biscuit

    $18.95

Breakfast Burritos

  • Served with homefries and mango salsa Sub fruit $1.50

  • Bandito Burrito

    Scrambled eggs, crisp bacon, potato, roasted red pepper & smoked gouda

    $13.95

  • Domingo Burrito

    Creole-style scrambled eggs, pulled pork, avocado mash & white cheddar cheese with crunchy corn tortillas

    $14.95

    spicy

  • Original Burrito

    Scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, peppers, onion & jack cheese

    $13.95

  • Gringo Burrito

    Egg whites, turkey, baby spinach & jack cheese wrapped in a warm whole wheat tortilla

    $13.95

Scrambles

  • Served with home fries and toast, sub fruit $1.50 Add multi-grain, cinnamon swirl, English muffin or bagel $1.50 * Small size subtract $2.00 * Sub egg whites $2.50

  • Miss Lucy's Tortilla Scramble

    Creole-style scrambled eggs, sausage, potato, green onion, served on two corn tortillas with melted cheddar & sour cream

    $14.95

    spicy

  • Ranchero Quesadilla

    Scrambled eggs, black bean, roasted corn & roasted red peppers with melted jalapeno jack on a grilled whole wheat tortilla

    $14.95

  • Hawaiian Coast Quesadilla

    Scrambled eggs, pulled pork, red pepper, grilled pineapple & yellow cheddar

    $14.95

  • Denver Scramble

    Grilled ham, green pepper, mushroom & onion topped with cheddar cheese

    $13.95

  • Avocado Scramble

    Grilled turkey, roasted red pepper, green onion & avocado

    $13.95

  • Garden Gourmet

    Roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sun-dried tomato & sautéed onion

    $13.95

French Toast

  • Served with bacon, ham, sausage or turkey bacon Sub fruit $1.50 100% REAL maple syrup $2.50

  • Brioche French Toast

    Fresh strawberries & créme fraiche

    $11.95

  • BKYLN French Toast

    Stuffed with NY style cheesecake and topped with a warm berry compote

    $13.95

  • Apple Strudel

    Cinnamon apples & créme fraiche

    $13.95

  • The Krispy Nutella

    Fresh strawberry with a Nutella drizzle

    $13.95

  • Cinnamon Swirl

    Créme fraiche & powdered sugar

    $13.95

  • The Graham Cracker

    Peanut butter, sliced banana & caramel sauce

    $12.95

Pancakes

  • Served with bacon, ham, sausage or turkey bacon Sub fruit $1.50 | GLUTEN FREE $2.00 Maple pecan syrup $1.50 REAL maple syrup $2.50

  • Classic or Whole Grain

    $11.95

  • Chocolate Chip

    $12.95

  • Cinnamon Bun

    $12.95

  • Dulce De Leche

    $12.95

  • Sweet Potato Pie

    $12.95

  • Short Stack

    $6.95

  • Cookie Dough

    $12.95

  • Banana Walnut

    $12.95

  • Apple Crumb

    $12.95

  • Blueberry Pecan

    $12.95

Waffles

  • Sub fruit: $1.50 | GLUTEN FREE: $2.00 100% REAL maple syrup $2.50

  • Belgian w/ Fresh Berries

    Powdered sugar & whipped cream served with bacon, ham, sausage, or turkey bacon

    $12.95

  • Tennessee Chicken & Waffle

    Cinnamon sugar sweet potato waffle with spicy honey fried chicken

    $16.95

  • Whole Grain Waffle

    Fresh strawberries, sliced banana, powdered sugar & whipped cream served with bacon, ham, sausage, or turkey bacon

    $12.95

  • Chicken & Waffles

    Homebaked waffle with cornmeal-crusted fried chicken served with maple pecan syrup

    $16.95

Lite Bites

Today's Homemade Soup: $4.95 (cup) | $6.95 (bowl)

  • Soup & Salad Combo

    Small Size Greek, Caesar or Garden salad

    $10.95

  • BLT on Multi-Grain

    Toasted with basil mayo with choice of fries or salad

    $13.95

    Add avocado $2.50

  • Grilled Cheese Trio

    Melted cheddar, American, and swiss, with tomato on multi-grain w/ fries or salad

    $12.95

  • Apple, Brie& Bacon

    Grilled cheese with caramelized onion on multi-grain w/ fries or salad

    $13.95

Lettuce Continue...

Dressings: Raspberry Vin, Sweet Mustard Vin, Greek, Creamy Caesar, Ranch, Blue Cheese, 1000 Island, Balsamic

  • Classic Caesar

    Romaine hearts, shaved asiago

    $11.95

    Add:

    Chicken $2

    Shrimp $4

    Steak $8

  • Toast House Salad

    Grilled chicken, sliced green apple, red onion, crumbled gorgonzola cheese & toasted walnuts

    $13.95

  • Chicken in the Garden

    Homemade chicken salad on a bed of mixed greens with grape tomatoes, cucumber & red onion

    $13.95

  • Lemon Chicken Salad

    Grilled chicken, dried cranberries, toasted almonds & crumbled goat cheese with our own lemon dressing

    $13.95

Wraps & Flats

Served with french fries, garden, greek, or caesar salad
Sub sweet potato fries with maple dipping sauce 1.50

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap

    Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce & shaved asiago

    $13.95

    Sub Shrimp $4

  • Southwest Turkey Wrap

    Turkey, jack cheese, bacon, mixed greens, tomato, red onion & chipotle mayo

    $13.95

  • Sweet-n-Smokey Chicken & Portobello

    Roasted red peppers, goat cheese, baby spinach & balsamic glaze

    $14.95

  • Chicken Salad Wrap

    Our homemade chicken salad with apple, mixed greens & tomato

    $13.95

  • The Bad Larry

    Grilled turkey, avocado, white cheddar, red onion, and tomato on a toasted flat bread with avocado ranch dressing & crisp bacon

    $14.95

  • Roast Beef & Avocado

    White Vermont cheddar cheese, grilled onion, mixed greens, tomato with avocado-ranch

    $13.95

  • Hampton's Ham & Brie

    Honey Ham, cucumber, apple & brie cheese with mixed greens, red onions, toasted walnuts & sweet mustard vinaigrette

    $13.95

  • Bayou Flat

    Cajun grilled turkey, jack cheese, red onion, and tomato on toasted flat bread with chipotle mayo

    $14.95

    spicy

  • Sriracha Shrimp Wrap

    Shrimp, black bean, roasted corn, red pepper & mixed greens with sriracha mayo

    $15.95

    spicy

Steakhouse Burgers

Served with french fries, garden, greek, or caesar salad
Sub sweet potato fries with maple dipping sauce $1.50

  • New York

    Handmade 8oz. burger served with lettuce, tomato & red onion on a potato roll

    $13.95

  • Cheddar Bacon

    $15.95

  • Jack & Avocado

    $15.95

  • Homemade Chicken Burger

    Handmade 8oz ground chicken burger on a multi-grain roll

    $13.95

  • Impossible Burger

    All-natural veggie burger, with lettuce, tomato & red onion on a multi-grain roll

    $13.95

  • Make it Cheesy

    American, brie, cheddar, Monterey jack, mozzarella, pepper jack, swiss or goat cheese

    $1

  • Stack it Up

    Avocado, bacon, turkey bacon, caramelized onions, pulled pork, or sauteed mushrooms

    $2

Toast Specialties...

Served with french fries, garden, greek, or caesar salad
Sub sweet potato fries with maple dipping sauce $1.50

  • RB Famous

    Roast beef, grilled portobello, red onion & fresh mozzarella cheese on toasted focaccia with basil mayo

    $14.95

  • Brooklyn Chicken

    Grilled chicken, mushroom, spinach & fresh mozzarella on a garlic toasted multi-grain roll

    $14.95

  • Vienna Chicken

    Grilled chicken, spinach, sun-dried tomato pesto, and fresh mozzarella on a toasted multi grain roll

    $13.95

  • Turkey Reuben

    Turkey, melted swiss, sauerkraut on toasted rye with 1000 island dressing

    $14.95

  • The Breadwinner

    Chicken salad, gorgonzola cheese & tomato on toasted focaccia with thin cucumber slices

    $13.95

  • Nashville Fried Chicken

    Corn meal-crusted chicken, ham, swiss cheese, dijonnaise & mixed greens on a brioche bun

    $14.95

  • Cuban Reuben

    Pulled pork, ham, sliced pickle, coleslaw & melted Swiss on homebaked rye with spicy mustard

    $15.95

  • Chicken Fried Steak

    Chicken fried steak with homemade biscuits & sausage gravy

    $17.95

Quesadillas...

Served with french fries, garden, greek, or caesar salad
Sub sweet potato fries with maple dipping sauce $1.50

  • La Mesa

    Chicken, bacon, and avocado ranch with pickled red onion & white cheddar

    $14.95

  • The Smokey Valley

    Grilled steak, caramelized onion, mushroom with truffle oil & mozzarella cheese

    $14.95

  • The Lone Star

    Shrimp and Chorizo with black beans, jalapeno & pepper jack cheese

    $14.95

  • Buffalo Cauliflower

    Buffalo tossed cauliflower, mozzarella & pickled red onion

    $13.95

Cold Beverages

Small | Large

  • Homebrewed Iced Tea

    $2.75

    $3.50

  • Green Tea Iced Tea

    With pineapple

    $2.75

    $3.50

  • Iced Peach Tea

    $2.75

    $3.50

  • Fresh Fruit Iced Tea

    Fresh brewed dried berry blend

    $2.95

    $3.50

  • Lemonade

    $2.75

    $3.50

  • Strawberry Lemonade

    $2.95

    $3.50

  • Orange Juice

    $3.75

    $4.75

  • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

    $4.95

    $5.95

  • Organic Apple Juice

    $3.50

    $4.50

  • Organic Cranberry Juice

    $3.50

    $4.50

  • Chocolate Milk

    $2.95

    $3.95

  • Soft Drinks

    Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root beer & Ginger Ale

    $2.95

    $3.50

Smoothies

100% crushed

  • Mango

    $5.95

  • Strawberry Banana

    $5.95

  • Wild Berry

    $5.95

  • Pineapple Coconut

    $5.95

Coffee Drinks

Coffee By The Pound: MKT

  • Danish Breakfast Roast

    Vermont Maple Crunch / Cinnamon Hazelnut / Graham Cracker/ Swiss Almond Mocha

    $2.95

  • Café Latte / Cappuccino

    $3.95

    Mocha / Raspberry / Caramel / Dolce De Leche / Hazelnut / Dbl Chocolate / Vanilla/Toasted Almond $0.50

  • Iced Coffee / Cappuccinos

    $2.95

    $4.25

  • Peanut Butter Mocha

    $4.95

  • Chai Tea Latte

    $4.95

  • Caramel Apple Chai

    $4.95

  • Matcha Latte

    $4.95

  • Gourmet Hot Chocolate

    $4.95

  • Double Espresso

    $3.50

Mimosas & Marys

  • Orange

    $8.95

  • Pomegranate

    $8.95

  • Cranberry / Orange

    $8.95

  • Lemon / Blueberry

    $8.95

  • Madrid Red Sangria

    $8.95

  • Bloody Mary

    $10.95

  • Sriracha Shrimp & Bacon Bloody Mary

    $12.95

Kids Menu

  • Kids Scrambled Eggs

    With bacon served with toast

    $6.95

  • Kids French Toast

    With strawberries, bacon or sausage

    $6.95

  • Kids Chicken Fingers

    Served with french fries

    $6.95

  • Kids Silver Dollar Pancakes

    Bacon or sausage

    $6.95

  • Kids Crispy Nutella FT

    with strawberries, bacon or sausage

    $7.95

  • Kids Grilled Cheese

    On whole wheat w/ french fries

    $6.95

Sides

  • Side of Bacon

    $4.50

  • Side of Turkey Bacon

    $4.50

  • Side of Sausage or Ham

    $4

  • Biscuits & Gravy

    $6.95

  • Short Stack Pancakes

    $6.95

  • Side of Homefries

    $4

  • Side of French Fries

    $4.50

  • Side of Sweet Potato Fries

    $5.50

While we do have a shared kitchen with animal products, we do the best we can to avoid cross-contact. 

Breakfast Specialties

served with choice of home fries, garden salad, or french fries add fresh fruit or sweet potato fries for $1.50 Add to any dish! Vegan Mozzarella - $2.00 Fresh Avocado - $2.00

  • The Alchemist

    Two scrambled vegan eggs with your choice of fruit or vegan sausage, served with home fries and toast

    $14.95

  • The Yeasayer Omelet

    Vegan eggs & vegan mozzarella, served with home fries and toast

    $15.95

  • Mt. Shasta Scramble

    Vegan eggs, roasted zucchini, spinach, mushroom, sundried tomato, & sautéed onion, served with home fries and toast

    $16.95

  • Twin Sister Burrito

    Scrambled vegan eggs, vegan sausage, potatoes, peppers, & onions, served with home fries and mango salsa

    $16.95

  • Tofu Scramble

    Grilled tofu with spinach, zucchini, mushroom, asparagus & red pepper, served with home fries and toast

    $12.95

  • Coconut Multigrain French Toast

    Dipped in coconut milk & vanilla, topped with mangos and bananas, served with your choice side

    $13.95

Lunch Specialties

served with choice of home fries, garden salad, or french fries add fresh fruit or sweet potato fries for $1.50 Add to any dish! Vegan Mozzarella - $2.00 Fresh Avocado - $2.00

  • Beyond Burger

    with lettuce, tomato, and onion on a multigrain roll

    $15.95

  • Portabello Panini

    Grilled portabella mushrooms, vegan mozzarella, red onion, mixed greens, & sundried tomato pesto on a multigrain roll

    $16.95

  • Brooklyn Chicken

    Vegan breaded chicken, mushroom, spinach & vegan mozzarella on a garlic toasted multigrain roll

    $16.95

  • Vienna Chicken

    Vegan breaded chicken, spinach, sundried tomato pesto and vegan mozzarella on a toasted multigrain roll

    $16.95

  • Kids Chicken Fingers

    Vegan breaded chicken & french fries

    $7.95